中国环保产业政策工具的比较分析——基于GRA-VAR模型的实证研究

doi:10.18402/resci.2016.10.15

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 环保产业是连接环境与经济的桥梁,是“十三五”时期国家的重点建设内容,为更有效地促进环保产业发展,有必要对众多环保产业政策工具进行比较。本文基于国外经验及中国实际构建了中国环保产业政策工具分类的概念模型,并在此基础上应用中国环保产业营业收入和三类六项政策工具的1995-2014年数据构建GRA-VAR模型,通过测度政策工具对环保产业的重要程度及影响比较环保产业多项政策工具。研究得出：在促进环保产业发展三类政策中,科技政策工具最优、经济政策工具次之、法制政策工具最弱。其中,科技政策工具中代表成果的细分工具在六项细分工具中排名第五;经济政策工具作为经济手段,其与环保产业的关联程度高于另两类行政手段与环保产业的平均关联程度。

关键词: GRA-VAR模型, 环保产业, 政策工具比较, 政策工具分类, 中国

Abstract: As a key to combining economy and environment, the environmental industry has been recognized as an essential part of China’s 13th Five-Year Plan. In order to accelerate the development of the environmental industry,it is necessary to classify policy instruments and compare their effects on the environmental industry. This paper proposes a conceptual model to classify policy instruments in China's environmental industry. Based on this conceptual model, a GRA-VAR measurement model for comparison of the classified policy instruments is constructed. Based on the data for revenue and environmental policy instruments from 1995 to 2014,the importance of these policy instruments to the environmental industry is further measured. In this paper, the legal and technological policy instruments are used as the administrative means while the economic policy instrument is the economic means for analysis and discussion. The legal policy instrument has the least promotion effects on the environmental industry compared to the economic and technology policy instruments, which mainly results from the indirect effects on the environmental industry's revenue, the imperfect formulation and implement of regulations and the lack of effective mechanism of environmental standard revision. As the economic means, the economic policy instrument has a higher average correlation with the environmental industry compared to the policy instruments of the administrative means, because it costs less financial resources and triggers lower possibilities for rent-seeking or corruption. The technological policy instrument has the largest promotion effects on the environmental industry due to the critical role of technological innovations in the development of emerging industries, but the imperfect mechanism of the environmental technology achievement transformation enables little influence of the achievement promotion tool in this instrument on the environmental industry.

Key words: China, classification of policy instruments, comparison of policy instruments, environmental industry, GRA-VAR model

黄清子, 王振振, 王立剑. 中国环保产业政策工具的比较分析——基于GRA-VAR模型的实证研究[J]. 资源科学, 2016, 38(10): 1988-2000.

HUANG Qingzi, WANG Zhenzhen, WANG Lijian. An empirical analysis of policy instrument comparison in China’s environmental industry according to GRA-VAR modeling[J]. Resources Science, 2016, 38(10): 1988-2000.

参考文献

[1] 环境保护部. 关于环保系统进一步推动环保产业发展的指导意见[EB/OL]. （2011-04-05）[2016-08-18]. http：//www.gov.cn/zwgk/2012-06/29/content_2172913.htm. [Ministry of Environ-mental Protection. Guiding Opinions on Environmental Protection System to Promote the Development of Environmental Industry[EB/OL]. （2011-04-05）[2016-08-18]. http：//www.gov.cn/zwgk/2012-06/29/content_2172913.htm.]
[2] 赵云皓,孙宁,逯元堂,等. 环保产业发展规划技术与方法研究[J]. 环境科学与管理,2015,40（1）：25-28. [Zhao Y H,Sun N,Lu Y T, et al . Environmental protection industry development planning techniques and methods[J]. Environmental Science and Management ,2015,40（1）：25-28.]
[3] 国务院. “十二五”节能环保产业发展规划[EB/OL]. （2012-06-16）[2016-08-18]. http：//www.gov.cn/zwgk/2012-06/29/content_2172913.htm. [The State Department. 12th Five-Year Energy Saving and Environmental Industry Development Plan[EB/OL]. （2012-06-16）[2016-08-18]. http：//www.gov.cn/zwgk/2012-06/29/content_2172913.htm.]
[4] 环境保护部,国家发改委,国家统计局. 2011年全国环境保护相关产业状况公报[N]. 中国环境报,2014-05-14（11）. [Ministry of Environmental Protection,National Development and Reform Commission,National Bureau of Statistics. Bulletin of the National Environmental Protection Related Industry in 2011[N]. China Environment News,2014-05-14（11）.]
[5] Peters B G,Nispen F K M V. Public Policy Instruments：Evaluating the Tools of Public Administration（New Horizons in Public Policy[M].Cheltenham：Edward Elgar Pub,1999.
[6] 张成福,党秀云. 公共管理学[M]. 北京：中国人民大学出版社,2001. [Zhang C F,Dang X Y. Public Administration[M]. Beijing：China Renmin University Press,2001.]
[7] 王辉. 政策工具选择与运用的逻辑研究-以四川Z乡农村公共产品供给为例[J]. 公共管理学报,2014,11（3）：14-23. [Wang H. The logic of policy instruments’ selection and application：Taking the supply of rural public goods in Z Township Sichuan Province as examples[J]. Jounal of Public Management ,2014,11（3）：14-23.]
[8] 尚杰,李大全. 环保产业市场化驱动力分析[J]. 学习与探索,2007,（4）：147-149. [Shang J,Li D Q. Market driven analysis of environmental protection industry[J]. Study & Exploration ,2007,（4）：147-149.]
[9] 许士春,龙如银. 考虑环保产业发展下的环境政策工具优化选择[J]. 运筹与管理,2012,21（5）：187-192. [Xu S C,Long R Y. Optimal choice of environmental policy instruments considering eco-industry development[J]. Operations Research and Manage-ment Science ,2012,21（5）：187-192.]
[10] 李凡,刘沛罡,刘姿含. 中印信息技术产业创新政策工具比较研究[J]. 科技进步与对策,2015,32（15）：110-114. [Li F,Liu P G,Liu Z H. A comparative study on the innovation policy instruments of information technology industry in China and India[J]. Scinece & Technology Progress and Policy ,2015,32（15）：110-114.]
[11] 魏淑艳,郭随磊. 中国新能源汽车产业发展政策工具选择[J]. 科技进步与对策,2014,31（21）：99-103. [Wei S Y,Guo S L. China's new energy automotive industry development policy instrument selection[J]. Science & Technology Progress and Policy ,2014,31（21）：99-103.]
[12] 刘国涛. 绿色产业与绿色产业法[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境,2005,15（4）：95-99. [Liu G T. Green industry and green industry law[J]. China Polulation , Resouces and Environment ,2005,15（4）：95-99.]
[13] 毛如柏. 中国环境法制建设对环保投资和环保产业的影响[J]. 北京大学学报（哲学社会科学版）,2010,47（2）：134-137. [Mao R B. Chinese environment legal system’s impacts on the environ-mental protection investment and industry[J]. Journal of Peking University （ Philosophy and Social Sciences ）,2010,47（2）：134-137.]
[14] 王小萍. 环保产业发展的政策与法制环境[J]. 生产力研究,2003,（3）：190-192. [Wang X P. Policy and legal environment for the development of environmental protection industry[J]. Produc-tivity Research ,2003,（3）：190-192.]
[15] 杨芷晴,柳光强. 促进环保产业的财税政策质量探讨[J]. 财政研究,2014,（12）：82-86. [Yang Z Q,Liu G Q. Discussion on the quality of fiscal and taxation policies to promote environmental industry[J]. Financial Research ,2014,（12）：82-86.]
[16] 赵云皓,逯元堂,辛璐,等. 促进环保产业发展的财政资金政策实践与展望[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境,2012,22（5）：20-23. [Zhao Y H,Lu Y T,Xin L, et al . Practice and prospect of fiscal policy for development of environmental protection industry[J]. China Polulation , Resouces and Environment ,2012,22（5）：20-23.]
[17] 李树. 中国环保产业发展的投融资策略选择[J]. 经济社会体制比较,2014,（3）：60-69. [Li S. Strategy choice on investment and financing of the environmental protection industry’s development in China[J]. Comparative Economic & Social System ,2014,（3）：60-69.]
[18] 王珺红,杨文杰. 论环保投融资与环保产业发展[J]. 经济论坛,2008,（10）：39-42. [Wang J H,Yang W J. A research of environmental protection investment and developmen of environmental industry[J]. Economic Tribune ,2008,（10）：39-42.]
[19] 郭朝先,刘艳红,杨晓琰,等. 中国环保产业投融资问题与机制创新[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境,2015,25（8）：92-99. [Guo C X,Liu Y H,Yang X Y, et al . Investment and finacing on China’s environmental protection industry：Problems and solutions[J]. China Polulation , Resouces and Environment ,2015,25（8）：92-99.]
[20] 蒋洪强,张静. 环境技术创新与环保产业发展[J]. 环境保护,2012,（15）：31-34. [Jiang H Q,Zhang J. Environmental tech-nology innovation and the development of environmental pro-tection industry[J]. Environmental Protection ,2012,（15）：31-34.]
[21] 李健民,万劲波. 促进环境科技与环保产业协同发展的环境技术政策[J]. 中国科技论坛,2002,（1）：43-48. [Li J M,Wan J B. Environmental technology policy for promoting the coordinated development of environmental technology and environmental industry[J]. Forum on Science and Technology in China ,2002,（1）：43-48.]
[22] 托马斯·R·戴伊（著）.谢明（译）.理解公共政策（第十二版）[M]. 北京：中国人民大学出版社,2011. [ Thomas R D（Write）. Xie M（Translate）. Understanding Public Policy（Twelfth Edition）[M]. Beijing：China Renmin University Press,2011.]
[23] Woodside K. Policy instruments and the study of public policy[J]. Canadian Journal of Political Science ,1986,19（4）：775-793.
[24] Hood C. The Tools of Government[M]. London：Maemillan,1983.
[25] McDonnell L M,Elmore R F. Getting the job done：Alternative policy instruments[J]. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis ,1987,9（2）：133-152.
[26] Howlett M,Ramesh M. Studying Public Policy：Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems[M]. Toronto：Oxford University Press,1995.
[27] 宋秀杰,王绍堂,丁庭华,等. 美国的环保政策及对环保产业发展的影响[J]. 城市环境与城市生态,2000,13（5）：40-42. [Song X J,Wang S T,Ding T H , et al .The environmental protection policy in U.S.A and its effect on environmental protection indu-strial development[J]. Urban Environment & Urban Ecology ,2000,13（5）：40-42.]
[28] 李纪武. 美国环保产业发展政策研究及对武汉市环保产业发展的思考[J]. 科技进步与对策,2001,18（2）：173-175. [Li J W. Research on the development policies of environmental industry in the United States and consideration on the development of environmental protection industry in Wuhan City[J]. Science & Technology Progress and Policy ,2001,18（2）：173-175.]
[29] Macdonald D. Green Taxation and Environmental Policy[C]. Canada：Environmental Studies Association of Canada,1995.
[30] 许同舟. 芬兰环境产业及政策[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境,1998,8（2）：86-88. [Xu T Z. Finland environmental industry and policies [J]. China Population , Resources and Environment ,1998,8（2）：86-88.]
[31] 王莉,赵庚科. 发达国家环境产业政策对我国的启示[J]. 人文杂志,2007,（2）：85-88. [Wang L,Zhao G K. The enlightenment of environmental industry policy in developed countries to China[J]. The Journal of Humanities ,2007,（2）：85-88.]
[32] 环境保护部. 关于环境科学技术和环保产业若干问题的决定[EB/OL].（1997-04-08）[2016-08-18]. http：//www.zhb.gov.cn/gkml/zj/wj/200910/t20091022_171884.htm. [Ministry of Environmental Protection. Decision on Several Issues of Environmental Science & Technology and Environmental Industry [EB/OL].（1997-04-08）[2016-08-18]. http：//www.zhb.gov.cn/gkml/zj/wj/200910/t20091022_171884.htm.]
[33] 连志东. 环保产业发展影响因素的理论分析与实证研究[J]. 环境科学研究,2009,22（5）：627-630. [Lian Z D.Theoretical analysis and empirical study on the influencing factors of environ-mental protection industry development[J]. Research of Envieron-mental Sciences ,2009,22（5）：627-630.]
[34] 吴文清. 我国环保产业发展的影响因素研究[D]. 北京：北京林业大学,2014. [Wu W Q. The Study on the Factors Influencing the Development of China's Environmental Protection Industry[D]. Beijing：Beijing Forestry University,2014.]
[35] 高广阔,陈珏. 环保产业对国民经济增长的拉动作用的实证检验[J]. 统计与决策,2008,（15）：117-119. [Gao G K,Chen Y. An empirical test of the effect of environmental protection industry on national economic growth[J]. Statistics and Decision ,2008,（15）：117-119.]
[36] 李宝娟,王政,王妍,等. 基于调查统计的环保产业发展现状、问题及对策分析[J]. 环境保护,2015,43（5）：54-58. [Li B J,Wang Z,Wang Y, et al . Analyzing the current situation,problems and countermeasures of China's environmental protection industry using the statistics investigation[J]. Environmental Protection ,2015,43（5）：54-58.]
[37] 李树,陈刚,陈屹立. 环境立法、执法对环保产业发展的影响-基于中国经验数据的实证分析[J]. 上海经济研究,2011,（8）：71-82. [Li S,Chen G,Chen Q L. How do environmental legisl-ation and environmental enforcement influence on the develop-ment of environmental industry：An empirical analysis based on Chinese data[J]. Shanghai Economic Review ,2011,（8）：71-82.]
[38] 熊跃辉,谷雪景. 环保标准对环保产业的影响分析[J]. 中国环境管理,2015,（31）：1-4. [Xiong Y H,Gu X J. Effects of environmental protection standards on environmental industry[J]. Chinese Journal of Environmental Management ,2015,（31）：1-4.]
[39] 匡开宇,乔冕,白玫,等. 关于促进环保产业发展的经济政策研究[J]. 环境科学与管理,2014,39（11）：10-13. [Kuang K Y,Qiao M,Bai M, et al . Research on economic policies to promote environmental protection industry[J]. Environmental Science and Management ,2014,39（11）：10-13.]
[40] 原毅军,耿殿贺. 环境政策传导机制与中国环保产业发展-基于政府、排污企业与环保企业的博弈研究[J]. 中国工业经济,2010,（10）：65-74. [Yuan Y J,Geng D H. The transmission mechanism of environmental policies and sustainable develop-ment on environment protect industry of China：Based on research of government and prollutant corporation and environment protect corporaion[J]. China Industrial Economics ,2010,（10）：65-74.]
[41] 兰相洁,金秋萍,谭顺清. 促进节能环保产业发展的财税政策长效机制研究[J]. 当代经济管理,2013,35（8）：93-97. [Lan X J,Jin Q P,Tan S Q. Long-term mechanism research on the financial and tax policy for promoting energy-saving and environ-mental protection industries development[J]. Contemporary Eco-nomy & Management ,2013,35（8）：93-97.]
[42] 何凌云,祝婧然,边丹册. 我国环保投资对环保产业发展的影响研究-基于全国和区域样本数据的经验分析[J]. 软科学,2013,27（1）：37-41. [He L Y,Zhu J R,Bian D C. Research on the effect of China’s environmental protection investment to the environmental protection industry development：An empirical analysis based on the national and regional date[J]. Soft Science ,2013,27（1）：37-41.]
[43] Jaffe A B,Trajtenberg M,Henderson R. Geographic localization of knowledge spillovers as evidenced by patent citations[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics ,1993,108（3）：577-598.
[44] Pearson K. Mathematical contributions to the theory of evolution-III.Regression,heridity and panmixia[J]. Philosophical Trans-action of the Royal Society of London ,1896,187：253-318.
[45] 中国环境年鉴编辑委员会. 中国环境年鉴：1996-2015[M]. 北京：中国环境年鉴社,1996-2015. [China Environment Yearbook Editorial Board. China Environment Yearbook[M]. Beijing：China Environment Yearbook Press,1996-2015.]
[46] 国家统计局. 中国统计年鉴：1996-2011[M]. 北京：中国统计出版社,1996-2011. [National Bureau of Statistics. China Statistical Yearbook[M]. Beijing：China Statistics Press,1996-2011.]
[47] 智研咨询集团. 2013-2017中国空气污染治理材料市场研究及未来发展趋势报告[R]. 北京：智研咨询集团,2013. [Intelli-gence Research Consultation. 2013-2017 China Air Pollution Control Materials Market Research and Future Development Trends Report[R]. Beijing：Intelligence Research Consultation,2013.]
[48] 产业信息网. 2015年中国环保行业投资现状分析及优化对策建议[EB/OL]. （2015-06-29）[2016-05-26]. http：//www.chyxx.com/industry/201506/325594.html. [ China Industrial Information Network. Analysis of the Status Quo of China's Investment in Environmental Industry in 2015 and Suggestions for Optimization[EB/OL]. （2015-06-29）[2016-05-26]. http：//www.chyxx.com/industry/201506/325594.html.]
[49] 环保部. 全国环境统计公报（1995-2014）[EB/OL]. （2015-10-19）[2016-05-26]. http：//zls.mep.gov.cn/hjtj/qghjtjgb/. [Ministry of Environmental Protection. National Environmental Statistics Bulletin（1995-2014）[EB/OL]. （2015-10-19）[2016-05-26]. http：//zls.mep.gov.cn/hjtj/qghjtjgb/.]
[50] 国家民族事务委员会经济发展司. 中国民族统计年鉴：1998-1999[M]. 北京：中国统计出版社,1998-1999. [State Ethnic Affairs Commission. China’s Ethnic Statistical Yearbook：1998-1999[M]. Beijing：China Statistics Press,1998-1999.]
[51] 国家统计局,科学技术部. 中国科技统计年鉴：2008-2014[M]. 北京：中国统计出版社,2008-2014. [National Bureau of stati-stics,Ministry of Science and Technology. China Statistical Year-book on Science snd Technology：2008-2014[M]. Beijing：China Statistics Press,2008-2014.]
[52] 环保部. 环境保护科学技术奖获奖项目的公示（2011-2014）[EB/OL]. （2015-06-08）[2016-05-26]. http：//kjs.mep.gov.cn/kjjl/hjxm/. [Ministry of Environmental Protection. Environmental Protection Science and Technology award Winning Project Publi-city[EB/OL]. （2015-06-08）[2016-05-26]. http：//kjs.mep.gov.cn/kjjl/hjxm/.]
[53] 李懿洋. 甘肃省产业结构与经济增长的灰色关联分析[J]. 企业经济,2011,（5）：20-23. [Li Y Y. A grey correlation analysis of the industrial structure and economic growth in Gansu province[J]. Enterprise Economy ,2011,（5）：20-23.]
[54] 王珊,张安录,张叶生. 湖北省农用地整理综合效益评价-基于灰色关联方法[J]. 资源科学,2013,35（4）：749-757. [ Wang S,Zhang A L,Zhang Y S. Comprehensive benefits of farmland con-solidation in Hubei Province[J]. Resources Science ,2013,35（4）：749-757.]
[55] 严武,王辉. 中国资本市场与产业结构升级关系的实证研究-基于协整检验和灰色关联分析法[J]. 江西财经大学学报,2012,（2）：17-25. [Yan W,Wang H. An empirical study of the relationship between China’s capital market and industrial structure upgrade：Based on co-integration and gray correlation analysis[J]. Journal of Jiangxi University of Finance and Econo-mics ,2012,（2）：17-25.]
[56] 刘金培,汪官镇,陈华友,等. 基于VAR模型的PM2.5与其影响因素动态关系研究-以西安市为例[J]. 干旱区资源与环境,2016,30（5）：78-84. [ Liu J P,Wang G Z Chen H Y, et al . Dynamic relationship between PM2.5 and its influence factors in Xi’an city based on the VAR model[J]. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment ,2016,30（5）：78-84.]
[57] 李青,陈红梅,王雅鹏. 基于面板VAR模型的新疆农业用水与农业经济增长的互动效应研究[J]. 资源科学,2014,36（8）：1679-1685. [ Li Q,Chen H M,Wang Y P. The interactive effect of agricultural water and agricultural economic growth in Xinjiang[J]. Resources Science ,2014,36（8）：1679-1685.]
[58] 王军,邹广平,石先进. 制度变迁对中国经济增长的影响-基于VAR模型的实证研究[J]. 中国工业经济,2013,（6）：70-82. [Wang J,Zou G P,Shi X J. Impact of institutional change on China’s economic growth：An empirical study based on VAR model[J]. China Industrial Economics ,2013,（6）：70-82.]
[59] 环境保护部,国家质量监督检验检疫总局. GB3095-2012 环境空气质量标准[S]. 北京：中国环境科学出版社,2012. [ Ministry of Environmental Protection,General Administration of Quality Supervision,Inspection anf Quarantine. GB3095-2012 Ambient Air Quality Standard[S].Beijing：China Environmental Science Press,2012.]
[60] 世界卫生组织. 世界卫生组织关于颗粒物、臭氧、二氧化氮和二氧化硫的空气质量准则[EB/OL].（2006-02）[2016-08-18]. http：//apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/69477/3/WHO_SDE_PHE_OEH_06.02_chi.pdf. [WHO. WHO Air Quality Standards on Particulate Matter,Ozone,Ntrogen Dioxide and Sulfur Dioxide[EB/OL]. （2006-02）[2016-08-18]. http：//apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/69477/3/WHO_SDE_PHE_OEH_06.02_chi.pdf.]
[61] 城乡建设环境保护部. GB 3552-83 船舶污染物排放标准[EB/OL].（1983-04-09）[2016-08-18]. http：//kjs.mep.gov.cn/hjbhbz/bzwb/shjbh/ swrwpfbz/ 198310/ W020061027525396151625.pdf. [Ministry of Urban& Rural Construction and Environmental Pro-tection. GB 3552-83 Effiuent Standard for Pollutants from Ship[EB/OL].（1983-04-09）[2016-08-18]. http：//kjs.mep.gov.cn/hjbhbz/bzwb/shjbh/swrwpfbz/198310/W02006102752539615162 5.pdf.]
[62] 张晏,汪劲. 我国环境标准制度存在的问题及对策[J]. 中国环境科学,2012,32（1）：187-192. [Zhang Y,Wang J. Problems of China’s system of environmental standards and the counter-measures[J]. China Environmental Science ,2012,32（1）：187-192.]
[63] 李岩. 我国环境标准体系现状分析[J]. 上海环境科学,2003,22（2）：115-117. [Li Y. Analysis on the status quo of environmental standards system in China[J]. Shanghai Environmental Sciences ,2003,22（2）：115-117.]
[64] 王文美,陈瑞,魏丽超,等. 地方环境保护标准现状问题分析与对策研究[J]. 环境科学导刊,2010,29（5）：21-24. [Wang M W,Chen R,Wei L C, et al . Study on status analysis and counter-measures of local environmental protection standard[J]. Environ-mental Science Survey ,2010,29（5）：21-24.]
[65] 陈燕,蓝楠. 美国环境经济政策对我国的启示[J]. 中国地质大学学报（社会科学版）,2010,10（2）：38-42. [Chen Y,Lan N. Inspiration for our country from American environmental economic policy[J]. Journal of China University of Geosciences （ Social Sciences Edition ）,2010,10（2）：38-42.]
[66] 李永东,路杨. 日本的环境经济政策及其对我国的借鉴作用[J]. 现代日本经济,2007,156（6）：12-16. [Li Y D,Lu Y. Lessons from Japan’s environmental economic policy[J]. Contemporary Economy of Japan ,2007,156（6）：12-16.]
[67] 杨朝飞. 转变政府管理职能创新环境经济政策[J]. 环境保护,2008,（13）：4-10. [Yang C F. Transformation of government management function and innovation of environment economic policy [J]. Environmental Protection ,2008,（13）：4-10.]
[68] 纪晶华,许正良. 发展战略性新兴产业的关键是实现自主创新[J]. 经济纵横,2013,（1）：98-100. [Ji J H,Xu Z L. The key to the development of strategic emerging industries is to achieve inde-pendent innovation[J]. Economic Review ,2013,（1）：98-100.]
[69] 王治民,万宁,孙晓蓉,等. 环境保护科技成果转化政策思考[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2014,S2：172-174. [Wang Z M,Wan N, Sun X R,et al. Consideration on the transformation of scientific and technological achievements in environmental protection policy[J]. China Polulation , Resouces and Environment ,2014,S2：172-174.]