基于“场论”的游客不文明行为表达——以八达岭长城刻画为例

doi:10.18402/resci.2017.07.07

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

勒温“场论”指出人的行为是个体要素与其周围环境相互作用形成心理场的结果。游客在长城上刻画这种典型的不文明行为,也必然与个体要素和环境要素有着深层次的联系。立足“刻画是一种表达”的观点,研究发现：当个体需求与环境要素之间存在不和谐,游客对长城意义的认知并不完整时,便产生了刻画意义超越保护意义的心理场,从而依存情感原则以不文明行为呈现于公众面前,所以“心理场”意义失衡是不文明行为产生的根本动力系统。深入探究游客的表达诉求和旅游环境,发挥游客个体要素能动性和环境对个体的正向影响力,构筑参与型组织管理形态使不文明行为得到消解,必将为开发和保护旅游景观资源提供新途径。

关键词: 场论, 游客, 不文明行为, 刻画, 表达, 心理场, 长城

Abstract:

Under Lewin's Field Theory, behavior is the result of interactions between individuals and the environment,forming the psychological field. Carving and writing on the Great Wall of China is a typically uncivilized behavior and a hot issue in tourism research. Here,we took 4120 photos of tourist graffiti on the Great Wall of China to discuss this behavior. The behavior and content of graffiti on the Great Wall reflects changes in tourism activity,social interaction and consciousness;it also represents the inner demands of tourists. In the course of travel activities,the Great Wall is given a unique function as expression of space,carrying a variety of emotions,expression behavior,situational space utilization,group interaction and inclusion or exclusion,as well as rhetoric in response to many characteristics. Based on the viewpoint that graffiti is a kind of expression,we found that the psychological field with the meaning of graffiti beyond protection is produced when there is disharmony between individual needs and environmental factors,and tourist’ cognition about the meaning of the Great Wall is not complete. Therefore,uncivilized behavior is shown in public with emotional principles and unbalanced meaning of Field Theory acts as the fundamental driving force. Uncivilized behavior will be digested by researching the express demands and tourism environment of tourists to form participatory management and play a positive influence with individual initiatives and the environment; ultimately it will provide a new way for the development and protection of precious tourism landscape resources.

Key words: field theory, tourists, uncivilized behavior, graffiti, expression, psychological field, Great Wall

张建荣, 赵振斌, 张天然. 基于“场论”的游客不文明行为表达——以八达岭长城刻画为例[J]. 资源科学, 2017, 39(7): 1291-1302.

Jianrong ZHANG, Zhenbin ZHAO, Tianran ZHANG. Tourist behavior and expression based on field theory：graffiti on the badaling section of Great Wall of China[J]. Resources Science, 2017, 39(7): 1291-1302.

图/表 7

图1

图2

图3

图4

图5

图6

图7

参考文献 57

[1]	林德荣,刘卫梅. 旅游不文明行为归因分析[J]. 旅游学刊,2016,31(8):8-10.
	[Lin D R,Liu W M.Attribution analysis of tourists uncivilized behavior[J]. Tourism Tribune,2016,31(8):8-10.]
[2]	Pearce P L.Psychological studies of tourist behaviour and experi-ence[J]. Australian Journal of Psychology,1987,39(2):173-182.
[3]	Crick M.Representations of international tourism in the social sciences:Sun,sex,sights,savings,and servility[J]. Annual review of Anthropology,2003,18:307-344.
[4]	Lepak D P,Snell S A.Examining the human resource archi-tecture:The relationships among human capital,employment,and human resource configurations[J]. Journal of Management,2002,28(4):517-543.
[5]	王敬武. 旅游需要理论的创新与发展[J]. 北京工商大学学报(社会科学版),2004,19(2):80-85.
	[Wang J W.The innovation and development of tourist need theory[J]. Journal of Beijing Technology & Business University(Social Science),2004,19(2):80-85.]
[6]	Dolnicar S,Leisch F.An investigation of tourists' patterns of obligation to protect the environment[J]. Journal of Travel Research,2008,46(4):381-391.
[7]	余建辉,张健华. 基于经济学视角的中国游客不文明行为探因[J]. 华东经济管理,2009,23(10):121-124.
	[Yu J H,Zhang J H.The causes exploring about uncivilized behavior of Chinese tourists from the perspective of economics[J]. East China Eco-nomic Management,2009,23(10):121-124.]
[8]	Douglas A,Lubbe B A.Identifying value conflicts between stakeholders in corporate travel management by applying the soft value management model:a survey in South Africa[J]. Tourism Management,2006,27(6):1130-1140.
[9]	Gustafson P.Control and commitment in corporate travel mana-gement[J]. Research in Transportation Business & Management,2013,9:21-28.
[10]	Wang N.Rethinking authenticity in tourism experience[J]. Annals of Tourism Research,1999,26(2):349-370.
[11]	王寿鹏,高天好. 基于伦理维度的旅游研究综述[J]. 旅游学刊,2011,26(4):20-25.
	[Wang S P,Gao T H.A review about tourism studies based on the dimension of ethics[J]. Tourism Tribune,2011,26(4):20-25.]
[12]	Sandve A,Marnburg E,Qgaard T.The ethical dimension of tou-rism certification programs[J]. International Journal of Hospi-tality Management,2014,36:73-80.
[13]	孙九霞. 旅游发展与公民教育的交互作用[J]. 旅游学刊,2015,30(10):16-17.
	[Sun J X.The interaction between tourism development and civic education[J]. Tourism Tribune,2015,30(10):16-17.]
[14]	刘椰滨. 社会主义和谐社会视域下国内旅游者道德弱化问题研究[D]. 重庆:重庆师范大学,2011.
	[Liu Y B.A Study on the Demoralization of Domestic Tourists in the Perspective of Socialist Harmonious Society[D]. Chongqing:Chongqing Nor-mal University,2011.]
[15]	库尔特·勒温(著). 高觉敷(译). 拓扑心理学原理[M]. 北京:商务印书馆,2005.
	[Lewin K(Write). Gao J F(Translate). Prin-ciples of Topological Psychology[M]. Beijing:The Commercial Press,2005.]
[16]	刘宏宇. 勒温的社会心理学理论评述[J]. 社会心理科学,1998,(1):57-61.
	[ Liu H Y.A review of Lewin's theory of social psychology[J]. Science of Social Psychology,1998,(1):57-61.]
[17]	李敬. 国内游客不文明行为研究述评[J]. 管理学刊,2012,25(5):80-85.
	[Li J.A review of researches on uncivilized behavior of domestic tourists[J]. Journal of Management,2012,25(5):80-85.]
[18]	郑杨,郑先芳,朱莎. 基于游客认知的文明旅游传播路径研究[J]. 北京第二外国语学院学报,2015,37(7):26-33.
	[ Zheng Y,Zheng X,Zhu S.On the communication of civilized travel based on tourists' cognition[J]. Journal of Beijing International Studies University,2015,37(7):26-33.]
[19]	常直杨. 中国游客不文明行为分类及宣传教育研究[J]. 商业经济,2016,(11):30-31.
	[Chang Z.Classification of uncivilized behavior of Chinese tourists and the publicity and education[J]. Business Economy,2016,(11):30-31.]
[20]	李萌,何春萍. 游客不文明旅游行为初探[J]. 北京第二外国语学院学报,2002,10(1):26-28.
	[Li M,He C P.A preliminary study on tourist uncivilized behavior[J]. Journal of Beijing International Studies University,2002,10(1):26-28.]
[21]	王海龙. 视觉人类学[M]. 上海:上海文艺出版总社,2001.
	[Wang H L.Visual Anthropology[M]. Shanghai:Shanghai Litera-ture and Art Publishing House,2001.]
[22]	李涛,陈芸. 我国游客不文明行为及其管理[J]. 经济管理,2015,(11):113-123.
	[Li T,Chen Y.A research of the Chinese deviant tourist behavior and management[J]. Economic Management,2015,(11):113-123.]
[23]	郭鲁芳,张素. 中国公民出境旅游文明与软实力提升研究[J]. 旅游学刊,2008,23(12):18-22.
	[ Guo L F,Zhang S.A study on outbound tourism ethics of Chinese citizens and “soft power” upgrade[J]. Tourism Tribune,2008,23(12):18-22.]
[24]	王寿鹏. 文化视角下的旅游者不文明行为分析[N]. 中国旅游报,2011-03-23(11).
	[Wang S P. An Analysis of the Uncivilized Behavior of Tourists from the Perspective of Culture[N]. China Tourism News,2011-03-23(11).]
[25]	魏小安,李劲松. 对国人旅游行为与文明旅游的深层次思考[N]. 中国旅游报,2006-10-18(13).
	[Wei X A,Li J S. A Deep Reflection on Chinese Tourists' Behavior and Civilized Tourism[N]. China Tourism News,2006-10-18(13).]
[26]	昌晶亮,余洪. 旅游法对游客不文明行为全方位制约探讨[J]. 求索,2013,(12):219-220.
	[Chang J L,Yu H.A study on the comprehensive control of tourists' uncivilized behavior[J]. Seeker,2013,(12):219-220.]
[27]	胡华. 中国游客不文明行为归类及归因研究[J]. 生态经济,2014,30(7):116-118.
	[Hu H.A study on the classification and attribution of Chinese tourists' uncivilized behavior[J]. Ecolo-gical Economy,2014,30(7):116-118.]
[28]	邱宏亮. 道德规范与旅游者文明旅游行为意愿-基于TPB的扩展模型[J]. 浙江社会科学,2016,(3):96-103.
	[Qiu H L.Study on the relationship between moral norm and tourists’ civili-zation tourism behavioral intention:an extended theory of planned behavior model[J]. Zhejiang Social Sciences,2016,(3):96-103.]
[29]	林育彬. 从勒温“场论”审视景区游客社会公德不文明行为[J]. 辽宁行政学院学报,2010,12(8):155-156.
	[Lin Y B.A study on the behavior of tourists' social morality from the perspective of Lewin's field theory[J]. Journal of Liaoning Administration College,2010,12(8):155-156.]
[30]	李宏,赵冰. 游客“涂鸦”及其意义探讨[J]. 首都师范大学学报(自然科学版),2007,28(2):81-83.
	[Li H,Zhao B.Studies on graffiti and its meanings[J]. Journal of Capital Normal University,2007,28(2):81-83.]
[31]	Valle I,Weiss E.Participation in the figured world of graffiti[J]. Teaching and Teacher Education,2010,26(1):128-135.
[32]	Eyck T A T. Justifying graffiti:Redefining societal codes through orders of worth[J]. Social Science Journal,2016,53(2):218-225
[33]	高舜礼. 景区涂鸦堵与疏[N]. 中国旅游报,2012-07-23(02).
	[Gao S L. Blocking and Sparse about Graffiti in Scenic Spots[N]. China Tourism News,2012-07-23(02).]
[34]	Haworth B,Bruce E,Iveson K.Spatio-temporal analysis of graffiti occurrence in an inner-city urban environment[J]. Applied Geography,2013,38(1):53-63.
[35]	Megler V,Banis D,Chang H.Spatial analysis of graffiti in San Francisco[J]. Applied Geography,2014,54(95):63-73.
[36]	Shi Q,Li C G,Deng J Y.Assessment of impacts of visitors’ activities on vegetation in Zhangjiajie National Forest Park[J]. Journal of Forestry Research,2002,13(2):137-140.
[37]	晋秀龙,陆林,巩劼,等. 芜湖赭山风景区植物游憩刻画研究[J]. 安徽师范大学学报(自然科学版),2008,31(4):386-390.
	[Jin X L,Lu L,Gong J,et al.Research on the recreational depiction on plants in Zheshan Scenic Area,Wuhu City[J]. Journal of Anhui Normal University(Natural Science),2008,31(4):386-390.]
[38]	刘家延. 有意味的涂鸦:对一种视觉形式的解读[D]. 南京:南京艺术学院,2011.
	[Liu J Y.The Means of Graffiti:Interpret-ation of a visual form[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing Arts University,2011.]
[39]	吕虹. “涂鸦”:公共空间的私人表达[D]. 北京:北京大学,2008.
	[Lv H.Graffiti:Private Expression in Public Space[D]. Beijing:Peking University,2008.]
[40]	王寿鹏,旷婷玥. 从旅游者不文明行为到旅游者道德行为失范-旅游者道德行为连续体模型的构建[J]. 旅游研究,2011,3(2):56-61.
	[Wang S P,Kuang T Y.From the tourists' uncivilized behavior to tourists' anomie of moral behavior-the construction of tourists' moral behavior continuum model[J]. Tourism Research,2011,3(2):56-61.]
[41]	尼古拉斯·米尔佐夫(著).倪伟(译). 视觉文化导论[M]. 苏州:江苏人民出版社,2006.
	[ Mirzoeff N(Write). Ni W(Translate). An Introduction to Visual Culture[M]. Suzhou:Jiangsu People's Publishing House,2006.]
[42]	Erjavec A.The pictorial turn[J]. Nordic Journal of Aesthetics,2003,15:27-28.
[43]	龙迪勇. 图像叙事:空间的时间化[J]. 江西社会科学,2007,(9):39-53.
	[ Long D Y.Image narration:space of time[J]. Jiangxi Social Sciences,2007,(9):39-53.]
[44]	宁晓萌. 表达与存在:梅洛-庞蒂现象学研究[M]. 北京:北京大学出版社,2013.
	[Ning X M.Expression and Existence:Study of Merleau-Ponty’s Phenomenology[M]. Beijing:Peking Uni-versity Press,2013.]
[45]	Macdonald N.Making a World of Difference:The Personal Benefits of Subcultural Membership[M]. London:Palgrave Macmillan UK,2001.
[46]	Edensor T.Tourists at the Taj:Performance and meaning at a symbolic site[J]. Annals of Tourism Research,2000,27(1):239-241.
[47]	Bakhtin M M,Emerson C,Holquist M,et al.Speech genres and other late essays[J]. South Central Review,1986,5(1):115-115.
[48]	Kennedy G A.On rhetoric:A theory of civic discourse[J]. Classical World,2006,13(1):273-276.
[49]	Hitchcock M.The language of tourism:A sociolinguistic perspective. by Graham M. S. Dann[J]. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute,1998,4(3):562-563.
[50]	Maccannell D.The ego factor in tourism[J]. Journal of Con-sumer Research,2002,29(1):146-151.
[51]	樊友猛,谢彦君. 具身欲求与身体失范:旅游不文明现象的一种理论解释[J]. 旅游学刊,2016,31(8):4-6.
	[Fan Y M,Xie Y J.The body desire and body anomie:a theoretical explanation of tourism uncivilized phenomenon[J]. Tourism Tribune,2016,31(8):4-6.]
[52]	Jewitt C,Kress G.Multimodal Literacy[M]. New York:Peter Lang,2003.
[53]	李晋涛. 情感守恒假说及其认知意义[D]. 太原:山西大学,2007.
	[Li J T.The Hypothesis of Emotion Conservation and Its Cognitive Significance[D]. Taiyuan:Shanxi University,2007.]
[54]	Dolnicar S,Leisch F.An investigation of tourists' patterns of obligation to protect the environment[J]. Journal of Travel Research,2008,46(4):381-391.
[55]	Pearce P L.Tourist Behaviour and the Contemporary World[M]. Bristol:Channel View Publications,2011.
[56]	邱宏亮,吴雪飞,李镇华,等. 文明旅游意识对文明旅游行为意向的影响-基于国内游客与出境游客的比较分析[A]. 中国旅游研究院. 2014中国旅游科学年会论文集[C]. 北京:中国旅游研究院,2014.
	[Qiu H L,Wu X F,Li Z H,et al.Impacts of Civilization Tourism Awareness on Civilization Tourism Behavioral Intention:A Comparative Study of Domestic Tourists and Outbound Tourists[A]. China Tourism Academy. Sympo-sium of 2014 Chinese Tourism Science Annual Conference[C]. Beijing:China Tourism Academy,2014.]
[57]	Wisner K L,Gelenberg A J,Leonard H,et al.Pharmacologic treatment of depression during pregnancy[J]. Jama,1999,282(13):1264-1269.