三江源国家公园体制试点区生态旅游系统构建与运行机制探讨

doi:10.18402/resci.2017.01.06

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

生态旅游是三江源国家公园体制试点区建设的重要内容之一,社会-生态系统（SESs）理论作为新兴的可持续发展分析方法,为试点区生态旅游发展研究提供了新视角。本文在SESs框架下,构建了三江源国家公园体制试点区生态旅游社会-生态系统（E-SESs）,并探讨其运行机制。研究表明：①鉴于国家公园资源属性,将社会-生态系统理论运用于试点区生态旅游研究具有合理性与必要性;②试点区生态旅游系统由管理、运营、社区参与和公众支持4个子系统有机构成,以实现四维目标;③从系统变量间的相互作用关系出发,系统运行机制包含政府主导、分区利用、绿色运营、游客管理、环境教育、社区参与、公众支持7个方面。最后,提出未来研究需要关注的问题。

关键词: 三江源国家公园体制试点区, 社会-生态系统理论, 生态旅游系统, 运行机制

Abstract:

It is urgent that we understand two issues for the Sanjiangyuan National Park Pilot Area （SNP）：how to achieve sustainable development of ecological tourism,and how to release the contradiction between ecological protection and local economic development. Researchers are only now beginning to enter a phase where they can contribute to the decision-making processes. Social-ecological systems （SESs）theory is an emerging conceptual framework of sustainable development and provides a new perspective for SNP. This paper embedded SNP ecotourism into society-ecosystem circulation,applied SESs to SNP ecotourism research,and constructed an ecotourism system and operation mechanism under a SNP context. We found that the public attributes of SNP’s resources make it reasonable to turn to SESs theory. Interaction between core stakeholders （tourism manager,operators,communities,tourists,public and ecological attractions）forms the four functional systems of management,operation,community participation and public support,which facilitate the dimensions of ecology,culture,market demand and business. Based on the interaction between system-units,the operating mechanism should include seven aspects：government domination,zoning utilization,green operation,visitor management,environmental education,community participation and public support. Future research should look at how to enhance the operability of ecological tourism system operation mechanisms,and different subjects and different behaviors. There is also a need for explicit indexes under different state space and connection in a dynamic context involving elements of the system and the outside world.

Key words: ecotourism system, operating mechanism, Sanjiangyuan National Park System Pilot Area, social-ecological systems

向宝惠, 曾瑜皙. 三江源国家公园体制试点区生态旅游系统构建与运行机制探讨[J]. 资源科学, 2017, 39(1): 50-60.

XIANG Baohui, ZENG Yuxi. Ecotourism construction and operating mechanism in the Sanjiangyuan National Park System Pilot Area,China[J]. Resources Science, 2017, 39(1): 50-60.

参考文献

[1] Ceballos-Lascuráin H. Tourism,Ecotourism and Protected Areas：The State of Nature-Based Tourism around the World and Guidelines for Its Development[M]. Gland：IUCN,1996.
[2] 钟林生,马向远,曾瑜皙. 中国生态旅游研究进展与展望[J]. 地理科学进展,2016,35（6）：679-690. [Zhong L S,Ma X Y,Zeng Y X. Progresses and prospects of ecotourism research in China[J]. Progress in Geography ,2016,35（6）：679-690.]
[3] Merce I,Radac B,Milin A, et al . Forest National Park-an eco-tourism destination[J]. Journal of Biotechnology ,2016,231：S96-S96.
[4] Coggins G C,Glicksman R L. Concessions law and policy in the national park system[J]. Denver University Law Review ,1997,74（3）：729-777.
[5] Aymoz B G P,Randrianjafy V R. Randrianjafy,Z J N, et al . Com-munity management of natural resources：A case study from Ankarafantsika National Park,Madagascar[J]. AMBIO ,2013,42（6）：767-775.
[6] 张海霞,汪宇明. 可持续自然旅游发展的国家公园模式及其启示-以优胜美地国家公园和科里国家公园为例[J]. 经济地理,2010,30（1）：156-161. [Zhang H X,Wang Y M. National Park model and implications for the development of sustainable nature-based Tourism-Yosemite National Park and KOLI National Park case studies[J]. Economic Geography ,2010,30（1）：156-161.]
[7] 汪德根,Alan A L. 国家公园“门票经济”的公益性回归与管理体制改革[J]. 旅游学刊,2015,30（5）：11-13. [Wang D G,Alan A L. How to turn "Tickets economy" to public welfare and reform of management system in national park[J]. Tourism Tribune ,2015,30（5）：11-13.]
[8] Clark W C. Sustainability science：A room of its own[J]. Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences of USA ,2007,104（6）：1737-1738.
[9] Ostrom E. A general framework for analyzing sustainability of social-ecological systems[J]. Science ,2009,325（5939）：419-422.
[10] Berta M L,Marina G L,Ignacio P, et al . The conservation against development paradigm in protected areas：Valuation of ecosystem services in the Doñana social-ecological system （southwestern Spain）[J]. Ecological Economics ,2011,70（8）：1481-1491.
[11] 李佳,钟林生,成升魁. 民族贫困地区居民对旅游扶贫效应的感知和参与行为研究-以青海省三江源地区为例[J]. 旅游学刊,2009,24（8）：71-76. [Li J,Zhong L S,Cheng S K. Study on residents’ perception and participational behavior on the effect of poverty-Elimination by Tourism in Ethnic Poverty-sticken areas[J]. Tourism Tribune ,2009,24（8）：71-76.]
[12] 池静,崔凤军. 乡村旅游地发展过程中的“公地悲剧”研究-以杭州梅家坞、龙坞茶村、山沟沟景区为例[J]. 旅游学刊,2006,21（7）：17-23. [Chi J,Cui F J. A study on “The Tragedy of the Commons” in the process of the development of on-limits rural tourism destinations[J]. Tourism Tribune ,2006,21（7）：17-23.]
[13] 郑义. 中国之毁灭-中国生态崩溃紧急报告[M]. 香港：明镜出版社,2001. [Zheng Y. Destruction of China-An Emergency Report on China's Ecological Collapse[M]. Hongkong：Mingjing Press,2001.]
[14] Ostrom E,Dietz T E,Dolsak N E, et al . The Drama of the Commons
. Washington：National Academies Press,2002.
[15] Pritchett L,Woolcock M. Solutions when the solution is the pro-
blem：Arraying the disarray in development[J]. World Development , 2004,32（2）：191-212.
[16] Ostrom E,Nagendra H. Insights on linking forests,trees,and people from the air,on the ground,and in the laboratory[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences ,2006,103（51）：19224-19231.
[17] Campbell L K,Gabriel N. Power in urban social-ecological systems：Processes and practices of governance and marginali-zation[J]. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening ,2016,19：253-254.
[18] 夏翟帆. 经济制度环境危机的根源-以黄河鸟岛消失案例分析我国自然保护危机加速发生的原因[D]. 杭州：浙江大学,2004. [Xia Z F. Economic System：the Root of the Environmental Crisis?-Take the Representative Case of “the Tragedy of the Yellow River Bird Island” to Analyze the Cause of the Accelerating Nature Protection Crisis in China[D]. Hangzhou：Zhejiang University,2004.]
[19] 孙喜涛. 玛曲草原退化的人为因素分析[D].兰州：兰州大学,2010. [Sun X T. Human Factors for Maqu Grassland Degradation[D]. Lanzhou：Lanzhou University,2010.]
[20] Liu J,Dietz T,Carpenter S R, et al . Complexity of coupled human and natural systems[J]. Science ,2007,317 （5844）：1513-1516.
[21] 黄静波,肖海平,李纯,等. 湘粤赣边界禁止开发区域生态旅游协调发展机制-以世界自然遗产丹霞山为例[J]. 地理学报,2013,68（6）：839-850. [Hang J B,Xiao H P,Li C, et al . The coordination modes of ecological tourism in prohibition development zones of the juncture area of Hunan,Guangdong and Jiangxi provinces：A case study of the world natural heritage Danxia Mountain[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica ,2013,68（6）：839-850.]
[22] 杨桂华. 生态旅游可持续发展四维目标模式探析[J]. 人文地理,2005,20（5）：74-77. [Yang G H. Targeting model of sus-tainable development in eco-tourism[J]. Human Geography ,2005,20（5）：74-77.]
[23] Walker B,Holling C S,Carpenter S R, et al . Resilience,adaptability and transformability in social-ecological system[J]. Ecology and Society ,2004,9（2）：5-12.
[24] Holling C S. Understanding the complexity of economic,eco-logical and social systems[J]. Ecosystems ,2001,6（4）：390-405.
[25] Folke C,Carpenter S,Elmqubist T, et al . Resilience and sus-tainable development：Building adaptive capacity in a world of transformations[J]. Ambio ： A journal of the Human Environment ,2002,31（4）：437-440.
[26] 阚如良,詹丽,梅雪. 论政府主导与旅游公共服务[J]. 管理世界,2012,（4）：171-172. [Kan R L,Zhan L,Mei X. Discussions on the government leading and tourism public service[J]. Manage-ment World ,2012,（4）：171-172.]
[27] 许学工,Eagles P F,张茵. 加拿大的自然保护区管理[M]. 北京：北京大学出版社,2000. [Xu X G,Eagles P F,Zhang Y. Manage-ment of Nature Reserves in Canada[M].Beijing：Peking University press,2000.]
[28] 樊杰. 我国主体功能区划的科学基础[J]. 地理学报,2007,62（4）：339-350. [Fan J. The scientific foundation of major function oriented zoning in China[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica ,2007,62（4）：339-350.]
[29] 钟赛香,谷树忠,严盛虎. 多视角下我国风景名胜区特许经营探讨[J]. 资源科学,2007,29（2）：34-39. [Zhong S X,Gu S Z,Yan S H. Comprehensive discussion on business concession in China National Parks[J]. Resources Science ,2007,29（2）：34-39.]
[30] Randle E J,Hoye R. Stakeholder perception of regulating com-mercial tourism in Victorian National Parks,Australia[J]. Tourism Management ,2016,54：138-149.
[31] 李佳,陈佳,杨新军,等. 旅游社会-生态系统的运行机制-以西安市上王村为例[J]. 地理研究,2015,34（5）：977-990. [Li J,Chen J,Yang X J, et al . Research on dynamic mechanism of tourism-based social-ecological system using the minimum des-cription model：A case study in Shangwang village of Xi'an city[J]. Geography Research ,2015,34（5）：977-990.]
[32] Pietilä M,Fagerholm N. Visitors’ place-based evaluations of unacceptable tourism impacts in Oulanka National Park,Finland[J]. Tourism Geographies ,2016,18（3）：258-279.
[33] 李晓莉. 美国国家公园休闲土地管理中三个模型的应用及启示[J]. 人文地理,2010,（1）：118-122. [Li X L. Three conceptual frameworks in the process of recreation land management in American National Parks[J]. Human Geography ,2010,（1）：118-122.]
[34] 邵全琴,樊江文,刘纪远,等. 三江源生态保护和建设一期工程生态成效评估[J]. 地理学报,2016,71（1）：3-20. [Shao Q Q,Fan J W,Liu J Y, et al . Assessment on the effects of the first-stage ecological conservation and restoration project in Sanjiangyuan region[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica ,2016,71（1）：3-20.]
[35] Imran S,Alam K,Beaumont N. Environmental orientations and environmental behavior：Perceptions of protected area tourism stakeholders[J]. Tourism Management ,2014,40（1）：290-299.
[36] Jarzebski M P,Tumilba V,Yamamoto H. Application of a tri-capital community resilience framework for assessing the social-ecological system sustainability of community-based forest management in the Philippines[J]. Sustainability Science ,2016,11（2）：307-320.
[37] Akyeampong O A. Pro-poor tourism：Residents' expectations,experiences and perceptions in the Kakum National Park Area of Ghana[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism ,2011,19（2）：197-213.
[38] 陈耀华,黄丹,颜思琦. 论国家公园的公益性、国家主导性和科学性[J]. 地理科学,2014,34（3）：257-264. [Chen Y H,Huang D,Yan S Q. Discussions on public welfare,state dominance and scientificity of National Park[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica ,2014,34（3）：257-264.]
[39] 孙业红,闵庆文,成升魁,等. 农业文化遗产地旅游社区潜力研究-以浙江省青田县为例[J]. 地理研究,2011,30（7）：1341-1350. [Sun Y H,Min Q W,Cheng S K, et al . The community potential for tourism development in agricultural heritage sites：A case study of Qingtian County[J]. Geography Research ,2011,30（7）：1341-1350.]