基于规划文本分析的地质旅游资源价值演化研究——黄河石林案例

doi:10.18402/resci.2016.09.03

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

地质旅游资源是旅游吸引物的重要依托载体,其价值演化研究对于地质公园的发展具有导向意义,同时构成了制定符合特定时期地质旅游资源综合价值充分释放的政策依据。基于黄河石林国家地质公园历年规划文本,通过高频特征词提取,以特征向量中心性和中介度中心性为指标,对其地质旅游资源价值演化进行了评价。结果表明,地质旅游资源价值构成大致以2012年为界限分为两个阶段,即保护与开发兼顾时期和综合开发时期。第一阶段地质公园的特征较为明显,“地貌、公园、保护”三个词出现的频率最高, “保护、自然、公园、景观、旅游、景区”处于主导地位,“公园、保护”拥有最高的影响力度。第二阶段以旅游为主题,“旅游、景区、项目、规划”出现的频率最高,“旅游、景区、发展、规划、建设、服务”处于主导地位,“旅游”的影响力度最大。导致这种演化的直接原因在于经济利益驱动,而具有中国特色的管理体制下政府对地质旅游资源价值的定位是决定其价值取向,从而导致地质旅游资源价值演化的根本原因。研究认为,中国特殊国情下的制度环境与制度安排决定了地质旅游的发展路径,是新制度经济学在国内旅游产业的实践应用,而这种特征正是人地关系相互影响的有效验证。

关键词: 规划文本, 地质旅游资源, 价值, 特征向量中心性, 中介度中心性, 黄河石林

Abstract:

Geotourism resources are important material carriers of tourism attraction. It is of great significance to research geotourism resource value evolution in order to guide geopark development and provide a policy basis for geotourism resource comprehensive value release within a specific time. High-frequency words were extracted based on previous planning text and the Eigenvector and Betweenness Centralization were used as indicators to determine the geotourism resource value evolution of the Yellow River Stone Forest. From the evolution process we can see that the geotourism resource value can be divided into two stages：protection with development stage and comprehensive development stage. It is characterized by ‘geopark’ in the first stage. For example,‘landform,park,protection’ own the highest frequency,‘protection,nature,park,landform,tourism,scenic region’ are in dominant position,and ‘park,protection’ own the biggest impact. ‘Tourism’ is taken as the theme in the second stage. For example,‘tourism,scenic region,project,planning’ own the highest frequency,‘tourism,scenic region,development,planning,construction,service’ are in the dominant position,and ‘tourism’ owns the biggest impact. The direct reason why the value changed is because of economic interests. However,the government determines value orientation in China and this is the primary cause of the evolution. Our findings research suggests that the special national conditions of the Chinese institutional environment and institutional arrangements determine the geotourism development pathway and the application of the new institutional economics in the domestic tourism industry,and that this character is just an effective verification of the interaction of human-land relationships in geography.

Key words: planning text, geotourism resource, value, eigenvector centralization, betweenness centralization, Yellow River Stone Forest

王丽丽, 马晓龙. 基于规划文本分析的地质旅游资源价值演化研究——黄河石林案例[J]. 资源科学, 2016, 38(9): 1653-1662.

WANG Lili,MA Xiaolong. Geotourism resource value evolution based on planning text analysis for the Yellow River Stone Forest[J]. Resources Science, 2016, 38(9): 1653-1662.

图/表 4

表1

图1

表2

图2

参考文献 26

[1]	赵汀,赵逊. 地质遗迹分类学及其应用[J]. 地球学报,2009,30(3):309-324.
	[Zhao T,Zhao X.Geoheritage taxonomy and its application[J]. Acta Geoscientica Sinica,2009,30(3):309-324.]
[2]	Ghazi J M,Ólafsdóttir R,Tongkul F.Geological features for geotourism in the western part of Sahand Volcano,NW Iran[J]. Geoheritage,2013,5(1):23-34.
[3]	陈安泽,卢云亭. 旅游地学概论[M]. 北京:北京大学出版社,2001.
	[Chen A Z,Lu Y T.An Introduction of Tourism Geology[M]. Beijing:Publishing House of Peking University,2001.]
[4]	Hose T A.3G's for modern geotourism[J]. Geoheritage,2012,4(1):7-24.
[5]	方世明,李江风. 地质遗产保护与开发[M]. 武汉:中国地质大学出版社,2011.
	[Fang S M,Li J F.Study on the Geological Heritage’s Protection and Exploitation[M]. Wuhan:China University of Geosciences Press,2011.]
[6]	赵逊,赵汀. 从地质遗迹的保护到世界地质公园的建立[J]. 地质论评,2003,49(4):389-399.
	[Zhao X,Zhao T.The process from the geoheritage conservation to the construction of world geoparks[J]. Geological Review,2003,49(4):389-399.]
[7]	Prosser C D,Bridgland D R,Brown E J,et al.Geoconservation for science and society:Challenges and opportunities[J]. Proceedings of the Geologists’ Association,2011,122(3):337-342.
[8]	Dowling R,Newsome D.Geotourism:Geotourism's issues and challenges[M]. Elsevier:London,2006.
[9]	Gray M.Geodiversity:Developing the paradigm[J]. Proceedings of the Geologists’ Association,2008,119:287-298.
[10]	张朝枝. 旅游与遗产保护-基于案例的理论研究[M].天津:南开大学出版社,2008.
	[Zhang C Z.Tourism and Heritage Protection-The Theory Study Based on the Case[M]. Tianjin:Nankai Univer-sity Press,2008.]
[11]	王长生. 暂缓开发-地质遗迹资源开发利用中的一个重要原则[J]. 四川地质学报,2005,25(3):173-174.
	[Wang C S.Putting off development-an important principle of the development of geological vestiges resources[J]. Acta Geological Sichuan,2005,25(3):173-174.]
[12]	蒋芩,殷继成. 国家地质公园地质遗迹景观资源价值深度开发模式探讨-以四川安县国家地质公园为例[J]. 国土资源科技管理,2013,30(2):40-45.
	[Jiang Q,Yin J C.Research on deep exploitation model of geological relic sight resources valuation in National Geoparks:A case study of Anxian National Geopark[J]. Science and Technological Management of Land and Resources,2013,30(2):40-45.]
[13]	Wang L L,Tian M Z,Wen X F,et al.Geoconservation and geotourism in Arxan-Chaihe Volcano Area,Inner Mongolia,China[J]. Quaternary International,2014,349:384-391.
[14]	范文静,唐承财. 地质遗产区旅游产业融合路径探析-以黄河石林国家地质公园为例[J]. 资源科学,2013,35(12):2376-2383.
	[Fan W J,Tang C C.Geological heritage area tourism development and industry convergence:A case study on Yellow River Stone Forest[J]. Resources Science,2013,35(12):2376-2383.]
[15]	Thomas J S.Methods of Social Research[M]. Orlando,USA:Harcourt Collge Publishers,200l.
[16]	陆林. 旅游地理文献分析[J]. 地理研究,1997,16(2):105-112.
	[Lu L.Analysis on the documentations of tourism geography[J]. Geographical Research,1997,16(2):105-112.]
[17]	杨家骥. 以内容分析法改进网站内容之探讨[D].南投:暨南国际大学,2000.
	[Yang J J.A Discussion to Improve the Website Content with Text Content Analysis[D].Nantou:Jinan Inter-national University,2000.]
[18]	朱峰,吕镇. 国内游客对饭店服务质量评论的文本分析-以e龙网的网友评论为例[J]. 旅游学刊,2006,21(5):86-90.
	[Zhu F,Lv Z.The post-purchase evaluation of the China’s star rated hotel service quality:A content analysis of guest comments on third party hotel booking websites[J]. Tourism Tribune,2006,21(5):86-90.]
[19]	赵振斌,党娇. 基于网络文本内容分析的太白山背包旅游行为研究[J]. 人文地理,2011,26(1):134-139.
	[Zhao Z B,Dang J.The travel behavior of backpackers of Moutain Taibai based on internet text content analysis[J]. Human Geography,2011,26(1):134-139.]
[20]	孙小培. 基于网络评论的目的地游客满意度研究[D]. 上海:华东师范大学,2011.
	[Sun X P.A Study on the Tourists’ Satis-faction Based on the Online Reviews[D]. Shanghai:East China Normal University,2011.]
[21]	付业勤,王新建,郑向敏. 基于网络文本分析的旅游形象研究-以鼓浪屿为例[J]. 旅游论坛,2012,5(4):59-66.
	[Fu Y Q,Wang X J,Zheng X M.Study on tourism image based on web text analysis:Case of Gulangyu[J]. Tourism Forum,2012,5(4):59-66.]
[22]	李林艳. 社会空间的另一种想象-社会网络分析的结构视野[J]. 社会学研究,2004,(3):64-75.
	[Li L Y.A kind of imagi-nation of social space-structure of social network analysis[J]. Sociological Study,2004,(3):64-75.]
[23]	North D C.Institution Institutional Change and Economic Perfor-mance[M]. London:Cambridge University Press,1999.
[24]	胡敏. 风景名胜资源产权辨析及使用权分割[J]. 旅游学刊,2003,18(4):24-27.
	[Hu M.On the property rights of scenery resources and the separation of rights to use[J]. Tourism Tribune,2003,18(4):24-27.]
[25]	谢洪忠,刘洪江. 美国国家公园地质旅游特色及借鉴意义[J]. 中国岩溶,2003,22(1):73-76.
	[Xie H Z,Liu H J.The pro-perties of National Park of America and its significance used for reference[J]. Carsologica Sinica,2003,22(1):73-76.]
[26]	马晓龙. 区域旅游发展的非均衡性测度与适应战略研究[M]. 北京:中国旅游出版社,2015.
	[Ma X L.The Measurement and Promotion Strategy on the Unbalance of Regional Tourism in China[M]. Beijing:China Travel & Tourism Press,2015.]

2002年			2005年			2012年			2013年			2015年
高频词	频次	频率/%	高频词	频次	频率/%	高频词	频次	频率/%	高频词	频次	频率/%	高频词	频次	频率/%
地貌	43	1.00	地质公园	335	2.63	旅游	629	2.69	项目	155	1.22	规划	90	2.28
地质公园	42	0.97	旅游	147	1.15	景区	346	1.48	景区	69	0.54	旅游	79	2.01
景区	30	0.70	地质	118	0.93	游客	257	1.10	规划	49	0.38	用地	47	1.19
形成	30	0.70	规划	103	0.81	规划	179	0.77	旅游	48	0.38	景区	44	1.12
地质	25	0.58	游客	96	0.75	活动	133	0.57	休闲度假	45	0.35	旅游区	39	0.99
保护区	22	0.51	景观	95	0.74	项目	129	0.55	策划	35	0.27	区域	34	0.86
遗迹	21	0.40	资源	85	0.67	旅游区	109	0.47	文化	35	0.27	游客	33	0.84
旅游	19	0.44	接待	60	0.47	景观	100	0.43	景观	33	0.26	设施	30	0.76
景观	19	0.44	地貌	56	0.44	体验	94	0.40	游客	32	0.25	项目	26	0.66
开发	17	0.39	景区	49	0.38	开发	90	0.39	建筑	28	0.22	休闲	25	0.63

2002年		2012年
特征词	特征向量中心度	特征词	特征向量中心度
保护	0.377	旅游	0.489
公园	0.347	景区	0.380
自然	0.321	发展	0.289
景观	0.306	规划	0.239
旅游	0.297	建设	0.221
资源	0.262	服务	0.207
开发	0.232	项目	0.200
建设	0.223	设施	0.198
地貌	0.219	游客	0.198
规划	0.162	开发	0.155